Loading the library…
Showing 5 verified claims · placement decisions
For young children deprived of parental care, placement into stable, high-quality family (foster) care rather than institutional care produces lasting gains in cognitive ability, attachment security, and mental health; benefits are larger with earlier placement and greater placement stability, although some deficits persist.
Among children in out-of-home care, placement instability (frequent placement changes) is associated with worse behavioral and mental-health outcomes — especially externalizing problems and PTSD symptoms — and propensity-adjusted work indicates an effect of instability beyond children's baseline problems; the relationship is partly bidirectional, since behavioral difficulties also drive disruptions.
Children placed with kin (relatives) in foster care generally show greater placement stability and fewer behavioral and mental-health problems than children in non-relative foster care; but much of the behavioral advantage reflects selection, and rigorous designs that adjust for it find the stability benefit more robust than the behavioral and academic benefits, which are mixed.
For adolescents in out-of-home care, congregate (group/residential) placement is associated with worse outcomes than family-based foster care — including roughly 2.5 times the risk of delinquency in matched samples, worse behavioral outcomes meta-analytically, and more criminal referrals than treatment foster care in a randomized trial — though selection of higher-risk youth into congregate settings accounts for part of the difference, and the association is weakest for youth who were already delinquent.
Whether placing a maltreated child in foster care produces better or worse outcomes than leaving the child at home is genuinely unresolved: rigorous quasi-experiments using the same identification strategy reach opposite conclusions, effects apply only to "marginal" cases at the placement threshold, and the science supports neither a presumption for nor against removal.