U.S. Supreme Court · 2012
Miller v. Alabama
567 U.S. 460 (2012)
Holding
Held that the Eighth Amendment forbids a sentencing scheme that mandates life without parole for juvenile homicide offenders. Before imposing that penalty a sentencer must consider youth and its hallmark features -- immaturity, impetuosity, and failure to appreciate risks and consequences -- and how children are different; given juveniles' diminished culpability and heightened capacity for change, such sentences should be uncommon.
Claims this case relied on
Adolescents have a diminished capacity for self-regulation and impulse control relative to adults; the neural systems supporting cognitive control and behavioral inhibition mature gradually across adolescence and do not reach adult levels until the late teens to early twenties.
Evidence strength: HighScientific consensus: Established· adolescent self-regulation / impulse controlAdolescents are more susceptible than adults to peer influence and to external pressure or coercion, with susceptibility greatest in mid-adolescence; the mere presence of peers measurably increases adolescents' risk-taking and shifts their decisions toward immediate rewards.
Evidence strength: HighScientific consensus: Established· adolescent social influence / coercionAdolescent personality and character are still forming and are not reliable indicators of fixed adult character; most adolescents who engage in antisocial behavior, including serious offending, desist as they mature, so adolescent conduct is a poor predictor of irretrievable depravity.
Evidence strength: HighScientific consensus: Established· adolescent personality development / desistanceAdolescents weigh risks and rewards differently from adults: a reward-sensitive socio-emotional system matures earlier than the cognitive-control system, producing heightened reward-seeking, a weaker orientation to the future, and steeper discounting of delayed consequences during adolescence.
Evidence strength: HighScientific consensus: Established· adolescent risk/reward processingAt the population level, childhood adversity -- adverse childhood experiences (ACEs) such as abuse, neglect, and household dysfunction, and a harmful family or home environment -- is associated with an elevated risk of adolescent antisocial and delinquent conduct, in a graded, dose-response pattern (more cumulative adversity, higher average risk).
Evidence strength: HighScientific consensus: Established· childhood adversity / developmental criminology